Fed rate hikes would seriously hurt the US economy, as 3Q GDP shows

The US GDP data for the third quarter of 2016 is what investors, including us, have been waiting for, because it is much more relevant for future rate hikes than the job data, which the Fed claims to be caring about.

The job data has already been very strong for a long time, and thus if the Fed’s preoccupation is indeed the labour market, it must have already raised rates this year, which is not the case.

So the Fed, or at least Janet Yellen, is caring about the slowdown of the US GDP growth, and the new data showed that the slowdown is indeed ongoing, and rate hakes, if any, would put an end to the already weak growth.

The only accelerating figure

In the third quarter of 2016, the real GDP growth of the US turned out to be 1.50% (year-on-year). This number is above the last quarter’s number, which was 1.28%, but if we look into the details, we would know the economy is obviously slowing down.


Whereas most of the figures on the chart are still in their downtrend, there is only one that is rapidly recovering: exports. Very roughly speaking, the GDP data this time is only supported by the rebound of the oil prices and still low rates, and everything else is sinking.

Consumption supported by low rates

Personal consumption grew 2.58% during the quarter, slowing down from 2.71% in the previous quarter.


Looking at the chart, one figure is obviously accelerating: durable goods. As durable goods mainly consist of cars, we may assume this is because long term interest rates went down this year as the expectation for rate hikes has weakened since the beginning of the year, so that interest rates for loans went down. This hypothesis could be proven by seeing the following chart:


The rates started to decline at the beginnings of 2014 and 2016, and those two timings are exactly when consumption of durable goods started to recover. So cars are driving the consumption due to low loan interest rates. This would be harmed by rate hikes.

Investment also supported only by low rates and recovering oil prices

Fixed investment grew -0.71%, slowing down from the previous quarter’s 0.83%. This number is horrible especially considering it was growing 4% in 2015.


The radical fall of residential investment even with low rates is quite alarming. Structures are recovering presumably because of low rates and rebounding oil prices. As we will also see in exports and imports, what we need to care about this time is only those two factors.

Exports grew because of rebounding oil prices

Exports grew 1.98%, massively rebounding from the previous quarter’s -1.14%. Imports also slightly recovered to be 0.66% from the last quarter’s 0.35%.


Exports were the only driving figure in the GDP data this time. If we look at the details, it was again the oils. The oil prices only started to rebound in the former half of 2016, and exports hit the bottom in the last quarter of 2015, but the data shows exports of oils have been recovering so. This could be because the fall of the oil prices are due to the oversupply not the low demand.


The conclusion is obvious: both consumption and investment are still on the downtrend, and only the low rates and the oil prices are supporting the US economy.

Considering this, is the December rate hike possible? In terms of macroeconomics, it would put an end to the already weak growth, but the GDP growth of 1.50% could not be enough for Ms Yellen to convince the other members. She is now fighting alone against the old-fashioned central bankers.

So the question is merely how much the Fed would make a mistake. The December rate hike would be seriously harming the economy, but the Fed minus Ms Yellen could ignore it.

In either case, we know the economy better than the Fed, and then we can seek investment opportunities when the Fed fails. We have already experienced the same thing in 2008.